Bai Yansong, member of the National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference: Medical disputes are not a shield of criminal behavior

Recently, when it comes to the injury incident sought by the public, Bai Yansong, a member of the National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC), said he did not want the media to interpret it as a doctor-patient contradiction when there were malignant injuries and violent injuriesViolence is a crimeTherefore, from the point of view of the cure and cure, the road to go is the cure, but it has a long roadBai Yansong: First of all, for many media, including the public, we should solve a confusing concept, we often describe violent wounded doctors as doctor-patient relationships or doctor-patient contradictions, no, this is two different thingsViolence is illegal, it is a crimeAnother point, on January 20, Zhong Nanshan academician on behalf of the expert group said "people-to-people", the same day there was actually a very sad vicious injury incidentexperienced this Wuhan defense war and Hubei defense war, I think all of us have a more sober understanding of health care workers, to protect the lives and health of our health care workers have reached a greater consensusHope that our future law can give health care workers better protection, at the same time in the aspect of the treatment of the law to cure the problem, there should also be a certain standard, such as some hospitals can explore the way of security and so onIn addition, the civil code also emphasizes the legal protection of health care workersthe news on Weibo, DrTao Yong,who personally experienced the injury was topping the first spotYes, "doctor-patient contradiction" is by no means an excuse for "illegal crime""dispute" arises from the conflict between two interests, and "injury" is unilateralTo portray the act of violence against doctors as a dispute between doctors and patients is itself a violation of the human rights of medical personnelpatients will hurt doctors, will this problem always haunt millions of health care?Not long ago, at a time when the outbreak was at its most intense and everyone relied heavily on medical care, social media was full of praise and thanks to the medical staff, and there were still many violent injuries that affected our anger and the helplessness of our medical staffbecause of long waiting times, Hubei two new crown rehabilitation people beat doctors
March 30, a document about the Hubei Hanchuan People's Hospital doctors were beaten by patients, caused social concern "incident" documents said that two new corona pneumonia rehabilitation people in the hospital on March 27 to review CT, because the waiting time is too long, rushed into the scanning room to scratch technician Huang a doctor at Ordos City Center Hospital in Inner Mongolia was bruised by his patients
at 12:45 p.m on March 19, 2020, Dr Tang Meng, the chief physician of the hemorrsome department of The East Sheng Department of Ordos City Hospital, was ready to give the patient dialysis, the patient suddenly stabbed Dr Tang with a knife, causing Dr Tang to suffer multiple injuries in his upper left arm, shinbone and abdomen The assailant was brought under control on the spot wife in the emergency room rescue, husband because of nursing problems injured nurse March 7, 16 o'clock, the patient pay a traffic accident resulting in spinal injury, in the emergency room rescue, her husband Wang a certain because of nursing problems with Shengjing Hospital, Nanhu Hospital District emergency room male nurse dispute, and then, the fist to the nurse, resulting in the nurse's face, nose and hand bruises drunk man in the ambulance "playing hooligans", but also beat female nurses
March 2 at 18:00, Shangdu County Hospital two female nurses with 120 emergency center driver sending the injured Wang (in a state of intoxication) on the way to the hospital, was "sexual harassment" by patients, persuasion process, one of the female nurses was beaten it is understood that at that time, two female nurses in the 120 emergency vehicle on Wang's injury routine examination, Wang a left hand to grab one of the female medical staff right hand, and also touch the female medical staff thigh part In the process of persuasion, the female nurse was beaten with a fist by Wang, causing soft tissue bruising in the forehead When 120 ambulances entered the county hospital, Wang caught another female nurse's right hand, let her hand still hold, and then was thrown away A man in Yancheng, who did not wear a mask and smoke, was reminded to beat the doctor on the evening of February 6, the suspect Tang drank, and then went to the hospital to visit his in-patient father, not only not wearing a mask, but also smoking in the oxygen-intake ward The on-duty doctor reminded Tang to put on a mask and stop his smoking who knows, after the wine Tang did not listen to, but with the doctor had a dispute, and then hit two doctors In a nearby villager can not see, came forward to discourage, was also beaten by Tang It was determined that all three of the beaten men were slightly injured , two doctors at Wuhan City's 4th Hospital were beaten by the families of patients with the new coronavirus, their protective clothing was torn on January 29, two doctors at the fourth hospital in Wuhan City were beaten by the families of a patient with a new coronavirus pneumonia It is understood that the hitter is a new type of coronavirus pneumonia family members, because of the death of the patient will be sprinkled on the doctor, and beat two doctors, but also two doctors' protective clothing tore off in fact, the sudden death of the patient, family sadness can be understood, but will be sprinkled on the doctor, beating the doctor will also tear off the protective clothing, in this special thing, is undoubtedly murder, unforgivable a violent injury in the eye of Chaoyang Hospital in Beijing, medical staff were cut
January 20 at about 1:55 pm, Chaoyang Hospital ophthalmology incident occurred violent injuries, a total of three medical staff were cut, and another patient was injured, of which Dr Tao Yong was the most serious injury, the back of the head and arm was cut it is understood that in the ophthalmology room on the 7th floor of the outpatient building, the director of ophthalmology, Dr Tao Yong, is receiving treatment, a patient's family knife d'art will work Dr Tao Yong cut Dr Tao Yong, with several knives in his body, ran out of the clinic, and the wounded man chased Dr Tao from the 7th floor to the 6th floor, and was subdued by security guards Meanwhile, two other medical staff members in the eye were cut during the pull." at that time, Tao Yong's deputy ophthalmologist Yang Shuo stood up and went forward to grab the knife in the hands of the assailants, and was cut hands and ears There was also a volunteer and a family member of the patient who was injured, and one of the mothers who took her child to see a doctor was mistakenly injured yes, this is Dr Tao Yong, who praised Bai Yansong these are the tragic facts that have occurred at a time when people think that doctors and patients are the most united 2018 White Paper on the Practice of Physicians in China shows that 66% of physicians in China have experienced conflicts between doctors and patients, and more than 30% of doctors have experienced violence by patients in the latest annual survey of NHS staff, 14.5 per cent of staff said they had experienced physical violence from patients, their families or the public November 2019, a survey released by the Korean Medical Association showed that 15 percent of 1,455 respondents had been physically assaulted and 10.4 percent physically assaulted in the past three years 2018 White Paper on the Practice of Physicians in China shows that 66% of physicians in China have experienced conflicts between doctors and patients, and more than 30% of physicians have experienced violence by patients these figures, the probability of medical violence in China seems much higher than in other countries from a vertical point of view, from the doctor more than 50 years of Hu Dayi believes that until the early 1970s and early 1980s, the doctor-patient relationship is very harmonious "In the meantime, I haven't seen a doctor, i've killed a doctor, and it's rare to scold a doctor Doctors' salaries are fixed, and at the same time, they have social dignity In an interview, Hu said change seems to have occurred in the last 30 years in Hebin's view, the root cause of this change lies in the administrative monopoly "The chinese doctor-patient contradiction is the result of the administrative monopoly of public hospitals under the planned economic system, which is not compatible with the market environment that has been transformed over the past few decades, thus leading to a general decline in public opinion of public hospitals." "
Hebin mentions that patients who are spoiled by the market economy want a better medical experience In Hu Dayi's description, the entire medical system, only technology, no service the frequency of medical violence at the same time, the crackdown on "medical trouble" and other repressive measures are more and more, but Hu Dayi did not see things calmed down, but more and more intense "This is a problem in the process of the alienation of the medical system, no matter how long it takes, and ultimately it is to be solved, and it is also the top-level design of health care reform that needs to be addressed." "The list of victims of medical violence in China continues to grow, although there are still medical violence during the outbreak, and the doctor-patient relationship does not appear to be showing any signs of abating call can't solve the problem, the law is the least absent against medical violence, in recent years, the country has issued a number of laws and regulations In 2015, the Criminal Law Amendment (9) promulgated, for the first time, "acts of disruption of the medical order" into the crime of gathering public to disturb social order; On March 26, 2020, the 20th meeting of the Standing Committee of the 15th National People's Congress of Beijing was held, and six safety prevention system measures were proposed to provide preventive companionship for high-risk patients, and to grant medical personnel the right to avoid risk and to suspend the hospital conditionally in the process of legislation and security checks, the health community has heard some different voices in the circle "knife does not kill, is killing people", with more than 30 years of experience in public hospital management Wang Wei (pseudonym) has told the health community, although security can block the entry of some knives, but if someone and medical staff conflict, in a hurry, any of the same items in the hospital may become a murder weapon "The security facilities at the hospital may just be a set-up "
socially, setting up security checks in hospitals seems to artificially put doctors and patients on the opposite side "Security screening sits in hospitals to protect medical personnel, but not only violence, killing, but all patients and their families "He bin is concerned that this measure will make patients and their families feel uncomfortable, when the discomfort continues to accumulate, the outbreak of contradictions, the injured or medical personnel." "Hospital security makes no sense at the level of protecting the health care community "
if injury is inevitable, is it possible to prevent more incidents and the less happens?" we should also be clear that the protection of the medical community still needs to give the public a certain understanding of the current level of medical care and related regulations, so as to have a more rational attitude to face the disease On the other hand, law enforcement officials should have a high sensitivity to medical injuries, and cannot deal with criminal cases as ordinary contradictory cases hope that more clear and perfect provisions will come out at an early date and land at an early date (original title: "Medical dispute" is not a shield of criminal acts)